Note the FB page. Yes, its from a group which seems to think that the Sheikh in the video destroyed non sectarian Muslims. It is a pure sign that they have not read the Quran. As for the Sheikh, he is just using all the tools he has to con the Muslims. You can watch the video here.
He says, "every hadith is authenticated for your benefit".
I truly enjoyed his body language here. When he says "for your benefit" he takes his eyes away from the people. He pretends to look downward which is a clear sign that he knew he was lying because even their so called most educated scholars say that not hadiths are fully correct.
Anyways, to make himself look confident and courageous, he quotes verse 16:89 which Quran only Muslims have taken as clear sign from Allah that hadiths are not needed in Islam. However, just like a perfect fraud, he doesn't give his audiences the number of the verse. Moreover, cunningly, he quotes only a tiny portion of it. He goes something like: "And we have sent down upon you the book as clarification for everything". Full verse is given below.
Full 16:89:
And [mention] the Day when We will resurrect among every nation a witness over them from themselves. And We will bring you, [O Muhammad], as a witness over your nation. And We have sent down to you the Book as clarification for all things and as guidance and mercy and good tidings for the Muslims.
The reason why we stay limited to Quran is because IT has everything clarified which we can use as GUIDANCE to remain on the right path. He omits the guidance part entirely so to make it look like "Quran has the laws, but guidance on how to apply them come from hadiths".
But his conning does not end there. In fact, his entire speech is full of fake claims. It is hilarious that he says that we fail to read Quran correctly or read whatever suits our desire, but as we will continue refuting his fake claims you will see he is the one who keeps doing it.
He says that in that same surah, we have "And we have sent down the book upon you so you may clarify for the people". As usual, the guy doesn't give the verse number which happens to be 16:44. There is a reason why he doesn't give the verse number. It just helps him trick people into thinking that verse 16:89 comes before 16:44. In his own words:
"In the same Surah, this is the Surat An-Naĥl , a few verses away, a few ayat away, Allah says And we have sent down the book upon you so you may clarify for the people"
He knows very well that majority of the sectarians won't go to Quran to check what he is saying because they have blind faith in whatever fraud scholars like him spit as truth. Consequently, he would get away with his tricks. The screenshot of FB shown above actually proves that. The admin just heard this guy and decided that he finished the Quran only Muslims. Now verse 89 is surely connected to 44. But if you start reading from 44 and go till 89 you will know the clarification that Prophet Muhammad was supposed to do was the Quran itself. In short, he was to just recite the message. In fact, verse 16:64 directly reaffirms that the clarification is the Quran itself. Take a look:
And We have not sent down the Book (the Quran) to you (O Muhammad SAW), except that you may explain clearly unto them those things in which they differ, and (as) a guidance and a mercy for a folk who believe
Debunking the scholar's claim: if we try to agree with this guy we have to ask where are the hadith books of other Prophets because 3:187 makes the same statement about the prior people. Check the arabic words in both the verses. They are the same.
Interestingly, Allah debunks the scholar's claim even with this verse:
And thus do We diversify the verses so the disbelievers will say, "You have studied," and so We may make the Qur'an clear for a people who know.6:105
In short, the Prophet did not explain the Quran through hadiths. All explanations are right within the Book. Allah has diversified the verses for this reason.
No comments:
Post a Comment